Vitebsk city executive committee refused to make a separate list for a dwelling of social use invalid of the second group of human rights of activist Valery Misnikov. The formal reason for this was the certificate of residence and family composition , issued Misnikov payment center number 4 of the state enterprise " ZHRET Pershamaiski district."

Under current law , unemployed single invalids of the first and second groups, which are registered in need of better housing conditions , are eligible for the dwelling of social use of public housing .

Valery Misnikov , without a doubt, belongs to this category of people defined by the legislation : he currently lives alone in a rented room , has no job and has only one source of income - pension granted to him upon reaching retirement age.

Pensions account for a significant part of the utilities. After Valery pays the full cost of public services, as well as benefits , which are supposed to belong to him under the law , do not apply to disabled people who rent housing.

The ex-wife and his two adult children live separately . They have many years of living separately , do not lead with Valery joint household , do not support him morally and financially. In fact , it's strangers . Therefore Misnikov considers himself a citizen living alone , and a former member of the family , which would seem to allow him to get social housing.

However, the certificate of residence and family composition , given by the settlement center number 4 ZHRET completely crossed all expectations Valeria . After all, in reference indicated that V. Misnikov registered and lives in an apartment with his ex-wife and a family of four people. That is, according to the reference , Misnikov not alone citizen, husband and father , who is under the care of his wife and children. On the basis of the document issued by the ZHRET , Misnikov Vitebsk city executive committee refused to enroll him in the lists for social housing .

For protection of their rights and legitimate interests of Valery Misnikov went to court Pershamaiski district of Vitebsk with a lawsuit to invalidate the certificate ZHRET and empowering its status as a lone citizen and former member of the status of the family. However, the judge refused Natalia Brovko Misnikov to meet its requirements. It is suggested that human rights arguments are not convincing , and the testimony of witnesses about his actual residence lonely is not based on the rule of law.

Appeal to the aide of the President, the Chief Inspector of the Vitebsk region Damashkevich no avail . On a personal reception Valery Misnikov gave details to the Assistant Head of State about the nature of the business, and he promised to investigate .

On behalf of Damashkevich versed in managing the affairs of the Vitebsk Oblast Executive Committee Alexei Matyushko . Last reported: "The fact of living in a village with you ( Vitebsk ) your able-bodied children , influenced the adoption of the Vitebsk City Executive Committee decision not to include you in a separate list for a dwelling of social use , by a certificate from the March 23, 2012 number 791 on the place of residence and family members issued by the billing center number 4 of the state enterprise " ZHRET Pershamaiski area." Documentary evidence of this fact and adopted on its basis an administrative decision does not lead you to assign any legal status to unauthorized it official. Thus, you declared " violation of regulations " that resulted in infringement of your rights and legal interests have not been confirmed , the reasons for response are absent . "

Invalid attempts to assert their rights and seek justice have failed. And the real reason for this failure - not a certificate issued ZhRETom and soulless bureaucratic state machine that formal piece of paper to put up housing problems of the disabled person.